Facebook
X
Pinterest
Copy Link
Once a buyer finds a property they’re serious about—whether it’s in Livingston, Paradise Valley, Gardiner, or one of the surrounding communities—the next big step is figuring out how to stay protected without making the deal so complicated that it feels “undoable” or unreasonable to the seller’s side.
That’s something a good agent should hlep you with and also where inspections, appraisals, and contingencies come in.
Used well, they give both the buyer and seller sides clarity. Used poorly, they can create stress, confusion, and unnecessary risk. Here’s how I usually explain these pieces in our market.
What an Inspection Really Is (and Isn’t)
An inspection is a chance for the buyer to understand the condition of what they’re buying—house, systems, outbuildings, and sometimes parts of the land.
In this area, it often goes beyond just a general home inspection. Depending on the property, buyers might also bring in:
- Well testing and evaluation
- Septic inspection and pumping
- Roof inspection
- Chimney or wood stove inspection
- Structural or foundation specialist (for certain homes)
For rural or higher-end properties with shops, guest cabins, barns, or unique features, we may talk about whether it makes sense to inspect those separately.
A good inspection:
- Identifies safety issues
- Flags items nearing the end of their useful life
- Helps the buyer understand ongoing maintenance and realistic future needs of the property.
What it doesn’t do is create a guarantee that nothing will ever go wrong. Homes in Montana deal with real winters, wind, sun, and age. The goal is an informed decision, not a promise of perfection.
How Buyers Can Use the Inspection Period Wisely
For buyers, the inspection period is your window to:
- Have the property components looked at with a professional set of eyes
- Prioritize what truly matters (safety, structure, major systems)
- Decide whether to move forward, renegotiate, or terminate the agreement and away from the transaction.
Smart use of that time usually looks like:
- Scheduling inspections early in the contingency timeframe window
- Attending the inspection in person, if you can, or at least having a call with the inspector afterward (live video such as FaceTime can be very helpful as well).
- Asking your agent to help you separate “normal for the age and area” from genuine red flags
From there, we can talk about whether it makes sense to ask the seller for:
- A repair on specific items
- A closing credit so you can handle things your way later
- A combination of sales price credit and requested repairs
- No changes at all, (if you’re comfortable and everything feels reasonable for the property)
What Sellers Should Expect During Inspections
If you’re the seller, it helps to know that inspections are fairly standard and not a sign that the buyer doesn’t “trust” you or has major reservations about the property. The inspection may actually help reduce your liability as the buyer learns more about the property before moving in.
What you can expect:
- Inspectors and sometimes additional specialists will be on the property for several hours. It is usually best if you’re gone during this time so they can fully focus on the task at hand
- Once the inspector has finished going through things, they’ll normally have a walk-through with the buyers so they can tell them their findings and answer any follow-up questions. This portion usually takes anywhere from 30 minutes to an hour or so
- The inspector will then prepare and deliver a written report that highlights everything from major concerns to minor maintenance items. Normally, the buyer will receive this report within a day or two after the inspection
Where it gets real is what happens after the report:
- Buyers may request repairs or credits for specific issues
- They may accept the property as-is
- In some cases, they may decide it’s not the right fit and elect to terminate the transaction
Your best position as a seller usually comes from:
- Being up-front about known issues
- Handling obvious safety or “show-stopper” items before you list, when possible
- Staying calm and pragmatic when the report comes back and the buyer submits their “Inspection Notice” of items they object to
Appraisals: What They Are and Why They Matter
If a buyer is financing the purchase, their lender will very often require an appraisal.
An appraiser’s job is to give the lender an opinion of value for the property as security for the loan. It’s not a full inspection, and it’s not the same thing as a market analysis from a local agent.
In our area, appraisals can be especially nuanced when properties are:
- On larger acreage
- Very unique in design or location
- In areas with fewer directly comparable recent sales
Appraisals can differ depending on the type of financing a buyer is getting. For instance, property conditin requirements for a government backed loan (VA, FHA, etc.) may be stronger than those of a conventional loan. Discussing these situations with your agent, prior to agreeing to the original offer, can help prepare you for items that may come up as a result of the appraisal.
Sometimes the appraised value lines up neatly with the contract price. Sometimes it comes in higher. And sometimes, it comes in lower than what the buyer and seller agreed on.
When that happens, there are options:
- Renegotiate the price
- Have the buyer bring in additional funds
- Challenge the appraisal with additional support (if applicable)
- Terminate the transaction, depending on how the financing contingency is written
The key is to understand those possibilities before you’re in the middle of them.
Contingencies: Protection With a Purpose
Contingencies are conditions that must be satisfied, waived or released for a purchase to move forward. Common ones include:
- Inspection contingency
- Preliminary Title Commitment contingency
- Property Insurance contingency
- Financing contingency
- Appraisal contingency
- Sometimes, a sale-of-home contingency for buyers who need to close on another property first or concurrently
Used thoughtfully, contingencies:
- Give buyers time to investigate and do their due diligence after their offer has been acceppted
- Give sellers a clear timeline for when uncertainty should be resolved
- Lay out what happens if certain things don’t go as planned
Problems usually arise when contingencies are vague, overly long, or stacked in a way that leaves one side carrying all the risk.
When I’m working with you, we’ll talk through:
- Which contingencies you truly need
- How much time is realistically necessary for each
- How to write them so expectations are clear on both sides
Balancing Protection and Strength as a Buyer
In a competitive situation, buyers sometimes feel pressure to waive everything “just to win.” On the other hand, loading an offer with layers of long contingencies can make it unattractive.
A strong, balanced offer might look like:
- Keeping inspection and appraisal contingencies, but with realistic, clearly defined timelines
- Using your pre-approval and financial documentation to show you’re serious
- Being specific about what you’re most concerned about (for example, well and septic) instead of treating every small maintenance item as a deal-breaker
The goal is to protect yourself and present something that a reasonable seller can accept.
Staying Grounded as a Seller
For sellers, it’s easy to get frustrated when a buyer asks for anything after inspections, especially if you’ve cared for the property for years.
It usually helps to remember:
- Buyers are looking at the property through the lens of, “What happens in the first 1–3 years we own this?”
- Inspectors are paid to point things out; that’s their job
- A short list of thoughtful concessions can sometimes keep a good deal together and be cheaper than going back on the market
That doesn’t mean you have to say yes to every request. It does mean it’s worth looking at each one practically:
- Is this a genuine safety or systems issue?
- Is it something the next buyer will likely bring up too?
- What’s the total cost compared to the disruption of starting over?
We’ll talk through those questions so you’re not deciding based on emotion alone.
The Bottom Line
In Livingston, Paradise Valley, Gardiner, and the surrounding southwest Montana market, inspections, appraisals, and contingencies are simply tools. They’re not meant to be weapons, and they don’t have to turn into drama.
When they’re set up thoughtfully:
- Buyers get the information they need to move forward with confidence
- Sellers know what to expect and when
- Both sides understand the path from “offer accepted” to “keys changing hands”
If you’re thinking about buying or selling and you’re unsure how protected you’d actually be—or how much risk you’d be asked to take on—I’m happy to walk you through how this plays out in real transactions here, step by step.
